Stop Guessing Your Holiday Inventory: A Retailer’s Guide to Open-to-Buy

Every holiday season, independent retailers face the same gamble: how much should I buy? Thanksgiving falls on November 26, with Black Friday on November 27, and the National Retail Federation expects holiday sales to grow 4.2% to $1.013 trillion. Shoppers are ready to spend, but only if the right products are on your shelves. Buy too much, and your cash gets stuck in stock you’ll have to mark down. Buy too little, and customers leave empty-handed. Open-to-buy (OTB) planning replaces guesswork with a clear budget.

What Is Open-to-Buy?

OTB is the merchandise budget you still have left to spend after accounting for what’s on your shelves and what’s already on order. RELEX describes it as the link between your financial targets and category-level purchasing budgets. Shopify’s open-to-buy guide gives the standard formula:

OTB = (planned sales + planned markdowns + planned ending inventory) − planned beginning inventory

Then subtract anything already on order. For example, if you plan $20,000 in December sales, $2,000 in markdowns, and $18,000 in ending inventory, and you start the month with $25,000 in stock, your OTB is $15,000 at retail. With $4,000 already on order, you have $11,000 left to spend.

Why Guessing Is So Expensive

IHL Group research reported by Retail Insight Network estimates that overstocks and out-of-stocks will cost global retail about $1.7 trillion in 2026, or 6.2% of sales. Out-of-stocks account for nearly two-thirds of that. For an independent store, one bad buy can tie up a quarter’s worth of cash.

Four Steps to Put OTB to Work

1. Build a realistic sales plan by category. Start with last year’s actuals and adjust for current trends. A good OTB plan weighs more than demand. Celerant notes that it must also account for cash flow, storage capacity, and market risk.

2. Hold back a reserve. One widely cited merchandising guideline is to commit 60 to 80 percent of a seasonal buy up front and keep the remaining 20 to 40 percent open for in-season reorders. That reserve lets you chase what’s selling instead of guessing months ahead.

3. Set reorder points for your bestsellers. NerdWallet’s reorder point guide explains the formula: lead-time demand plus safety stock. If you sell 5 units a day, your supplier takes 14 days to deliver, and you keep 10 units as a buffer, reorder when you hit 80 units.

4. Respect lead times. Cin7’s peak season playbook points out that tariff exposure makes lead times even more important in 2026. It also reports that 37% of gift buying now happens in September and October. Late orders mean missed sales.

Review Weekly, Adjust Quickly

OTB isn’t a set-it-and-forget-it budget. Check sell-through by category every week. If a category runs ahead of plan, release reserve dollars to reorder. If it lags, cut future orders and plan markdowns early, before the post-holiday rush of returns and clearance.

Let 360 Retail Management Take the Guesswork Out of Buying

At 360 Retail Management, we help independent retailers turn sales data into confident buying decisions. Our Shopify-native tool, SKU Flow, automates purchase order entry and catalog management, so your inventory data stays accurate, and your OTB plan stays reliable

Ready to buy smarter for the rest of this season and 2027? Book a free demo or contact us today.


Related reading: How Much Should I Buy? OTB Basics · What Is Open-to-Buy? · How to Set Prices for Seasonal Sales

Categories
Get In Touch
360 Retail Management
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.